1 . Assess the Jaffee v. Redmond (1996) case and the effects this case has had for communication between counselor and customer.
On June 27, 1991, Mary Lu Redmond, a police officer, responded to a fight at an condo complex. Believing that Ricky Allen was about to stab a man he was chasing, the girl shot and killed him. The administrator of Mister. Allen's real estate, Carrie Jaffee, filed suit in Government District The courtroom alleging that Officer Redmond violated Mister. Allen's constitutional rights by utilizing excessive force.
Through the discovery period of the case, Ms. Jaffee learned that Officer Redmond had took part in in 50 counseling lessons with a clinical social worker, Karen Beyer (" Ms. BeyerвЂќ). Your woman sought usage of the paperwork taken by Ms. Beyer during those classes. Officer Redmond's attorney resisted the demand, arguing that disclosure needs to be prevented because of a psychotherapist-client advantage. The court allowed the request nevertheless neither Ms. Beyer nor Officer Redmond complied with it. The judge suggested the court that the refusal to turn more than Ms. Beyer's notes could possibly be considered a presumption the content with the notes might have been bad to Official Redmond.
The jury granted Allen's estate $45, 000 on the federal civil privileges claim and $500, 000 on her state-law claim. The Court of Appeals pertaining to the 7th Circuit corrected the award and ordered a new trial, concluding that a psychotherapist-client privilege should be known. Ms. Jaffee, on behalf of Mister. Allen's property, appealed for the US Great Court.
The questions ahead of the Court had been:
1 . be it appropriate for federal government courts to recognize a psychotherapist privilege beneath the federal rules of facts; specifically, N. R. Electronic. Rule 501; 2 . in the event the federal tennis courts recognize a psychotherapist advantage, should the privilege extend to confidential marketing and sales communications made to certified social staff; and a few. should the chat during a treatment session additionally any therapist's notes...